The ranking is ours. The facts about each game come from its publisher, from museums, and from the jury of the Spiel des Jahres, a German critics’ prize that has run since 1979.[1]

Top shelf

Hanabi

You hold your cards facing away from you, so everyone sees your hand but you. The team has to lay out fireworks in order of colour and number, and the only help is a small supply of hints. After three mistakes the game is lost. It won the critics’ prize in 2013, plays two to five people in about half an hour, and the name is Japanese for fireworks.[2] We rank it first because it turns a card game into a puzzle you solve out loud with friends, and the whole table wins or loses together.

Codenames

Two spymasters know which of 25 word cards belong to their team. They give a one-word clue and a number, and their teammates guess. A wrong card ends the turn, and the assassin card ends the game.[3] Vlaada Chvátil designed it. It is for four to eight players and takes about 15 minutes.[4] The jury’s example: “Tree – 3” could point at bark, trunk and apple. It gave Codenames the 2016 critics’ prize and said one game is often followed by a second.[4] It is the one to bring to a loud party. A clever clue feels like a magic trick, and a terrible one is funnier.

Good, with the right company

Rush Hour

A traffic jam in a box. You slide cars and trucks to clear a path for the red car to escape. Ravensburger, which sells the ThinkFun edition, lists it as a one-player game for ages eight and up that takes about ten minutes.[5] There is no opponent, so a stuck puzzle is your own fault, which is why we like it. It is also the one to take on a train.

Mastermind

One player makes a secret code of four coloured pegs, chosen from six colours. The other guesses, and after each guess is told how many pegs are the right colour in the right place and how many are the right colour in the wrong place. An Israeli postmaster and telecommunications expert, Mordecai Meirowitz, invented it in 1970. In 1976–77 the computer scientist Knuth showed that the guesser can always crack the code in five moves or fewer.[6] That is both its charm and its limit. It is the best two-player game here, and it gets less tense once you know the method.

Respected more than played

Clue

A pianist named Anthony Pratt, who worked in European hotels, and his wife Elva designed it in 1943 from the murder-mystery party games he had seen there. It was patented in 1947 and sat unmade for years because of post-war shortages. Waddington’s of London published it as Cluedo in 1949, and Parker Brothers published a slightly changed Clue in the US the same year. It has 324 possible murders, and the museum calls it one of the ten best-selling games.[7] The idea of ruling out suspects, rooms and weapons is excellent. A lot of an evening goes on waiting for your turn, which is why it sits down here.

Rubik’s Cube

Not a board game, but the most famous physical puzzle there is. Erno Rubik, a Hungarian design teacher, built the first one in 1974 and called it the Magic Cube. It reached shops as Rubik’s Cube in 1980, and within two years 100 million had been bought. Solving it means learning patterns that cubers call algorithms.[8] It is more a skill to learn than a game to play, and that is why it ranks last.